Welcome to New York City Pizza
New York City Pizza, located in Hilton Head Island, SC, offers an authentic taste of NYC-style pizza that has earned it a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. With a focus on quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods, their pizza boasts the perfect double-cooked snap and rich flavors. Signature dishes like the Margarita pizza and deep dish showcase a delightful cheese-to-dough ratio, ensuring satisfaction for even the pickiest eaters. The warm and friendly service from staff members like Mandi and Dominick adds to the welcoming atmosphere, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking flavor and comfort.
New York City Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Best pizza on the island of you like NYC style pizza. The staff is always pleasant. Say hello to Mandi and Diego
This is a good stop for reliably good New York style pizza. When we have gone in May, sometimes the inside bar where you pick up the food can be a little deserted and we've had to wait for a minute or two, but they are always nice. I think the calzone is a B/A-, which is great - most are B or less. The pizza options were also good - we had a Margarita pizza, which was really well done.
Always a good spot for perfect pizza. The slices have that perfect double cooked snap and flavor... Heaven.
Not sure about the recent reviews, but don’t listen to them! Dominick provided wonderful service and great conversation while we dined in. We had the deep dish and the cheese was awesome! Great stringy-ness to dough ratio. Our daughter is picky about pizza cheese and loved it. The deep dish had a great crust, crispy bottom and fluffy top so we had the best of both worlds. Would definitely come again and order take out if we were local. The prices match a local joint and not a huge chain. Don’t listen to the Karens and enjoy a great little place while you are vacationing. Bonus...right next to a Publix and ABC
Dont let the 3.8 stars fool you. this place was great. when we went there was only 1 waitress working and she did her best and was very nice. our food took a little bit of time but honestly it was worth the wait. again this was a monday with 1 waitress working. But the food was great i had the spaghetti and meatball, my kids had the pizza which was so cheesy, my husband had the Philly cheese steak sandwich all fresh and amazing. The environment was great not to loud and again very friendly definitely recommend
Came on a Saturday night. It wasn't busy. Pizza was SOO GOOD! Crust was good, portion size was great. I also got a house salad and it was big and filling. Their house vinaigrette looks like it's made in house and was really good. Service was great, bathrooms and dining area was clean. We don't drink but the bar looked really nice as well. They do have outdoor seating and corn hole boards. We visited from Charlotte NC region and I haven't found pizza close to us as good as this place! Overall I was very impressed. It was great. Would definitely come again if we are in the area again.
This was a wonderful experience from start to finish. Mandy was is so sweet and kind. The pizza is fantastic and the homemade vinaigrette is yummy. We were treated with a homemade slice of the best cheese cake we’ve ever eaten, wow how thoughtful. These people still know how to take care of their customers. PS. Pat, thank you for the matches .
Amazing pizza and eating establishment. Diago is an Awesome and super nice Manager. Get your pizza today!
Location
-
45 Pembroke Dr #105, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926, United States Hotline: +1 843-689-2229
Welcome to New York City Pizza, an authentic slice of New York nestled on Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. Located at 45 Pembroke Dr #105, this gem has garnered attention for its commitment to delivering the classic NYC-style pizza experience right on the coast. Renowned for its vibrant flavors and a menu that encapsulates the bold spirit of the Big Apple, New York City Pizza is a must-visit for any pizza enthusiast.
One of the standout features of New York City Pizza is the dedicated staff. Regular patrons, like Diana Kleeman, praise Mandi and Diego for their friendly service, making each visit a pleasant encounter. When you step inside, you're greeted not just by aromas of perfectly baked pizza but also by a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like home. And while some customers, like Rob Madrid, have noted brief waits during peak times, the consistently good quality makes the time spent worthwhile.
The menu shines with classic options, such as the delectable Margherita pizza, which has impressed diners with its authentic preparation. From the perfect snap of the crust to the rich flavor of the toppings, each slice encapsulates what makes New York pizza legendary. Todd Anderbery captures this sentiment, declaring it "Heaven" due to its double-cooked snap and robust flavor profile.
If you’re in the mood for something heartier, their deep-dish pizza is an absolute treat. Annette White described it as having a remarkable balance between crispy and fluffy textures—an embodiment of the best of both worlds. Even picky eaters will find joy in the well-executed cheese, a testament to the kitchen's attention to detail.
Beyond pizza, the menu extends to inviting options like calzones, spaghetti, and Philly cheese steaks, as Amanda Diaz highlights in her review. Families will appreciate the variety, with offerings that cater to all tastes, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied. The atmosphere is intimate yet lively, ideal for casual dining or a quick takeout after a day of relaxation on the island.
Don’t let the occasional low ratings deter you; New York City Pizza is about great food and genuine service amidst a friendly vibe. As you plan your visit, take a moment to appreciate not just the food but the people who make this place special. Stop by, say hello, and indulge in the flavors that reflect the heart of NYC right there on Hilton Head Island.